Angel (unicorn/pegasus) = Magic + Pepper + Pepper; or Magic + Pepper + Star.
Big Bad Bill (voodoo man) = Yellow Love + Black Star + Blue Star.
Blurp (blowfish) = Purple Moon + Pink Love + Black Love/Blue Moon.
Burnie (dragon) = 2 Red Apple + 1 Blue Daisy
Cali (mermaid) = Blue Moon + Pink Magic + Yellow Moon.
Chop Chop (monkey) = 3 Dragons.
Coolio (ice cream) = Pink Apple + Love + Black Star
Cutie Pie (cupcake) = Blue Dragon + Pink Star + Purple Daisy
Dipsy (cloud) = Red/Pink Moon + Yellow Moon + Yellow Love.
Dj Quack (duck) = Dragon + Moon + Star.
Doris (rhinosaurus) = 3 Moons.
Snookums (dinosaur) = 3 Stars.
Ecto (ghost) = Red Love + Black Love + Pink/Yellow Pepper.
Flumpy (pluff) = Black Moon + Red Magic + Red Star.
Fumble (starfish) = Red Star + Yellow Love + Red Star/? Magic.
General Fuzukie (warrior) = Yellow Love + Purple Star + Red Pepper.
Gigi (unicorn) = Blue Pepper + Red Moon + Yellow Pepper.
Gingersnap (roughed up cat) = Magic + Love + Pepper.
Gurgle (dragon) = Red Dragon + Yellow Magic + Purple Love.
Hansel (gingerbread) = Blue/Purple Dragon + Black Magic + Black Moon.
Honey (rabbit) = Red/Blue Magic + Yellow Love + Blue Apple
Humphrey (hippo) = Daisy + Magic + Pepper.
Iggy (floating purple creature) = Purple Daisy.
Jeepers (tiger) = Blue Apple + Pink Love + Red Daisy
Kissy (baby ghost) = Purple Star + Yellow Star + Black Magic.
Lady Meowford (white cat) = Blue Moon + Pink Moon + Purple Star.
Mr. Snoodle (elephant) = Red Pepper + Purple Magic + Blue Pepper.
Oddie (doughnut) = Yellow Star + Black Star + Purple Star.
Peppy Penguin (penguin) = Blue/Red/Black Moon + Purple Moon + Yellow Magic.
Pooky (dinosaur with egg on head) = 2 Magic Beans + Moon Orchid.
Priscilla (horse with tiara) = Yellow Apple + Red Moon + Blue Moon.
Professor Purplex (owl) = Red/Blue Dragon + Pink Love + Yellow Moon.
Purdy (pink fluffy cat) = Dragon + Moon + Dragon.
Shelby (turtle) = Blue Dragon + Black Dragon + Blue Magic.
Shishi (panda) = Black Daisy + Red Dragon + Yellow Pepper
Sooki-Yaki (ninja cat) = Purple Pepper + Red Magic + Yellow Magic.
Squidge (fluffy flying creature) = Star + Pepper + Dragon.
Stanley (seahorse) = 2 Love Berries + 1 Dragon Fruit.
Tiki (toucan) = Red/Purple Star + Pink Love + Red Love.
Waldo (nerdy squirrel) = Pink Love + Purple/Black Dragon + Red Star.